The Tribe of Dina: A Jewish Women's Anthology
In a chapter in Irena’s novel: The tribe of Dina, a Jewish women’s anthology; she shows how feminists view the Jewish religion as sexist. Non-Jews and non-religious Jews believe that most organized religions are Patriarchal. Many Jewish feminists are not considered Jewish by the religion because they are focusing more on feminist issues then their religion. She explains in this article the concept of how in Judaism, men are considered normative and women are the “other”. We discussed the topic of women as the “other” in many different scenarios in class. When talking about issues of gender discrimination, the other is described as the outsider or person different from a societal standard. This idea can be related to the way many persecuted groups of people feels in response to how society treats them. In the Talmud (a Jewish record of rabbinic discussions), women are described that they were put on earth solely for the purpose of catering to a males needs. This is one of the many examples where women are downplayed by the religion. Women were not allowed to be clergy for many years and are still not allowed in the Orthodox sect. Also during a teenager’s bar/bat mitzvah women are not allowed to read from the torah and perform most of their service in English, and the men read Hebrew and from the Torah. This indirectly discriminates against women. Irena attends a homosexual congregation in San Francisco. She did not feel accepted by the rest of the Jewish community to attend services with her partner. The act of lesbians and gays being alienated and discriminated against is seen all throughout our culture. Irena has a very big impact on culture because she fits the description of a child survivor, lesbian, Jewish writer. Not only is Irena a talented writer with an amazing survival story, many people can relate to the social and religious issues she addresses.
Irena is a truly amazing woman.
-Amy Katzman
I'm glad to see that you found some more information on Klepfisz. She is an amazing poet and an important political writer.
ReplyDeletethe holocaust is very close to my heart and I am glad you suggested her!!!!
ReplyDeleteHello Ladies,
ReplyDeleteI think Irena Klepfisz is a really interesting author and I am glad that you chose her! Klepfisz's work is so heavily influenced by her status as a holocaust survivor and as you point out in another post, she is still deeply involved in the modern Judaism so it is important that she is also critical of the times she doesn't feel included in it. Do you think this relates to what Dr. McDaniel was saying about artists telling stories to change the practices of the cultures they respect? You talk about her interpreting her culture as a lesbian. Does she also talk about being an "other" as woman as well?
Good job taking on such a complex artist!
~ Sarah Dougherty
I definitely think that this relates to artists trying to change their culture through their work. Art is an expression of emotions toward a subject and I duno if I could make the claim that Irene was trying to say something. I feel that she is just expressing personal feelings toward the holocaust and the religion. She doesnt talk about the concept of the other but you can draw the conclusion that she is writing to change the mentality that homosexuals should be treated differently in society.
ReplyDelete-Amy Katzman